Pizza Hut's pan crust is chewy, airy, and perfect for dipping. In general, though, Pizza Hut was the chain with the least amount of flavor and creativity.
Little Caesars had tasty toppings, nice sauces, and creamy cheese. The DEEP!DEEP! dish, Detroit-style deep dish, and stuffed crazy crust were all delicious.
Domino's was the most reliable chain in terms of every pizza component: crust, sauce, cheese, meat and veggies, and dips. However, some crust styles were lacking.
While most Papa Johns' crusts we tried earned a shrug, the garlic epic stuffed crust was absolutely peerless, making it the single best pie in fast-food pizza history.