Someone holding a pint of Ben & Jerry's.

The Discontinued Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream Flavors That Deserve A Comeback


NEWS

By POSIE BRIEN

A "Flavor Graveyard" headstone for Bovinity Divinity.

Bovinity Divinity

This flavor combined milk and white chocolate ice cream with miniature milk and white fudge cows. This "swirled" pint was an unusual pairing loved by fans.
A pint and bowl of creme brûlée ice cream.

Crème Brûlée

With a sweet custard ice cream and caramelized sugar swirl, this is one of the brand's less fancy offerings, but one reviewer criticized its sweet-on-sweet flavor.
Ben & Jerry's peanut butter jelly headstone

Peanut Butter & Jelly

Ben & Jerry's itself rated its Peanut Butter and Jelly flavor as one of its 10 weirdest flavors. Perhaps it is a flavor best left to the sandwich realm.
A pint of Schweddy Balls.

Schweddy Balls

Inspired by a "Saturday Night Live” sketch, this vanilla ice cream has a hint of rum and fudge-covered rum and malt balls, proving that the brand has a sense of humor.
A "Flavor Graveyard" tombstone of White Russian.

White Russian

This mix of coffee ice cream and Kahlua liqueur was a dream flavor for any ice cream fiends who love a good boozy drink, but it won't return from the Flavor Graveyard.