Steak in various levels of doneness on fork

The Steak-Ordering Trend That's Causing Real Problems

NEWS

By BETSY PARKS
Steak being cooked in pan
Cooks have long complained about overcooking expensive steaks, and this problem has only worsened with people ordering steaks by temperature and adding the word "plus."
Steak in pan with herbs
The "plus" denotes that the meat should be cooked a tiny bit more or less than the standard rare, medium rare, etc. — essentially, in-between temperatures.
Butter melting on steak
It's not clear where this ordering trend originated, but chefs report on a Reddit thread that the request has been made all over America, most commonly as "medium rare plus."
Person taking steak temperature
However, each category of doneness corresponds to a temperature: medium rare is 130-135 degrees Fahrenheit, and medium is 135-145 degrees. This leaves little wiggle room.
Steak with pink center
A medium-rare "plus" steak would be cooked to around 137 degrees without going over 140, which is difficult. Instead, servers often enter it as the next-highest temperature.